by Sarah Statz Cords
Ben Yagoda’s book Memoir: A History, has been sitting on my work table for a week now, staring at me reproachfully as I try and figure out how to review it. We have a tempestuous history, this book and I.
When I first started it, I fell in love. The entire first chapter held me enthralled; it was Yagoda’s own take on the popularity and ubiquity of memoirs in today’s publishing and reading environment. It read like a literal “who’s who” of memoir titles and authors–from Ishmael Beah to James Frey to John Grogan, Dave Pelzer to Augusten Burroughs to Elizabeth Gilbert, they’re all there. In this one pithy chapter Yagoda dissected numerous subgenres and types of the form, including celebrity memoirs, “misery memoirs,” “shtick lit,” blog memoirs, dad memoirs, and many more. I enjoyed that first chapter immensely.
And then, as sometimes happens in relationships, the magic faded. This is not the author’s fault. Yagoda gave me exactly what the book’s title promised: the history of memoirs, from Augustine’s The Confessions (circa the fifth century) all the way through to twentieth-century America (and beyond). And it was a good history, too. Well-written, comprehensive, with lots of titles thrown in as examples. Everything was as it should be, and I’m fascinated by memoirs as a form, so I should have been ecstatic. Instead I found myself skipping large chunks of text.
It really is a good book. If you’re interested in literary history or would like to know more about the roots of memoir writing, you need look no further. (And the final chapter wraps things up nicely, including some thoughts on the nature of memoirs, and the authors who sometimes make them up.) But I recognize that not all librarians have the time to plow through this comprehensive a history. In that case, I’d check it out from your own library and read just the first and last chapters (and there’s one in the middle about “truth” in memoirs which is also worth the time)–if you don’t know anything about memoirs when you start, you certainly will by the time you finish.









